NewAI summaries now on every product pageSee how →
Protein Pick and Mix logoProtein Pick and MixUnited Kingdom · proteinpickandmix.co.uk

7,000 products. Reviews on autopilot.

How a sports nutrition store with one of the UK's largest supplement catalogs automated review collection across every SKU.

BigCommerceHealth & WellnessBefore: BigCommerce4 min read

Protein Pick and Mix
Ant RodgersFounder, Protein Pick and Mix
Reviews moved
8,000+
Live in
One day
Previous tool
BigCommerce
Platform
BigCommerce
Sells to
United Kingdom
Instagram
35K followers

Protein Pick and Mix sells protein bars, shakes, supplements, snacks, and drinks from hundreds of brands. Founded in 2013 and based in Kent, England, the store lets customers mix and match trial sizes across a catalog of over 7,000 products. That business model creates a specific review problem: thousands of individual SKUs, each needing its own customer feedback to help shoppers pick the right flavour, texture, or brand.

The challenge

When your catalog has 7,000+ products, manual review management is not an option.

Protein bars and supplements are personal. One person's favourite whey flavour is another's worst purchase. Customers need honest feedback on taste, texture, mixability, and value before committing. But with 7,000+ SKUs from hundreds of brands, collecting and displaying reviews manually across the catalog was never going to work.

Catalog scale

7,000+ products across hundreds of brands. Sending review requests by hand for each one would take a full-time role.

Trust for ingestibles

Shoppers buying supplements want proof from real buyers. Generic star ratings without detail don't cut it for products you put in your body.

Headless limitations

Running a custom frontend meant most off-the-shelf review tools either broke or required heavy workarounds.

The store needed automated review collection that could cover the full catalog, a review form that captured what supplement buyers actually care about, and a platform that worked with their headless architecture.

“Automation that actually scales to 7,000 products, not just 70.”

The moment it clicked

Most review platforms work fine for a store with a few hundred products. Protein Pick and Mix needed one that could handle automated requests, reminders, and moderation across thousands of SKUs without constant manual oversight.

Why WiserReview

Why Protein Pick and Mix chose WiserReview

  • High-volume automation

    Automated review request emails and follow-up reminders across the full 7,000+ product catalog. No manual sends, no missed products.

  • Custom review forms

    Rating categories for taste, texture, value, and mixability. Photo uploads. The kind of detail supplement shoppers actually want before buying.

  • Headless-compatible

    Works with their custom frontend through API integration. No widget breakage, no layout hacks.

  • Google and Facebook reviews in one place

    Google My Business reviews (4.8 stars, 47 reviews) and Facebook page reviews (4.7 stars, 42 ratings) pull into the same dashboard. All reviews from all sources, managed together.

The switch

Setting up reviews on a headless store

Protein Pick and Mix wasn't migrating from another review tool. They needed a platform that could bolt onto their custom frontend and start collecting from scratch across 7,000+ products.

  1. 1

    API integration

    Connected WiserReview to the headless frontend via API. Product catalog synced.

  2. 2

    Review form configured

    Custom rating categories added for taste, texture, value. Photo upload enabled.

  3. 3

    Automation live

    Review request emails, reminders, and incentive rewards turned on across the full catalog.

No migration needed. The focus was getting automation running at scale from day one.

On the store

What shoppers see on proteinpickandmix.co.uk

WiserReview widgets are integrated into Protein Pick and Mix's custom frontend so reviews feel like part of the site, not a third-party add-on.

Star rating sits right under the product title, and the full review section appears below with filters, sorting, and verified badges.

Star rating and review count right under the product title on every product page.
Star rating and review count right under the product title on every product page.
Full review section with rating breakdown, filters, sorting, and customer photos.
Full review section with rating breakdown, filters, sorting, and customer photos.

Live on the store

  • Star rating with review count on product pages
  • Product review section with rating breakdown and filters
  • Review wall page with all reviews across the store
  • Photo reviews from customers
  • Floating trust badge across all pages
  • Sorting by most recent, highest rated, and media-only

A real review from the store

Verified buyer

I'm not usually a big fan of whey protein because it often has a weird aftertaste and I usually only ever have clear whey but I had seen per4m everywhere so decided to give it a go as I wanted to have protein porridge more moving into the winter months. I got the carrot cake flavour and it's soooo good! It's not hideously sweet but sweet enough to satisfy that craving. It mixed so smoothly into my porridge without making it too thick. I also added sultanas and it was just spot on. Would 100% buy again and I look forward to trying the other flavours. Bonus points for it being gluten free!

Ellie, United Kingdom · Per4m Whey Protein Powder 900g · Sep 09, 2023

On autopilot

Automated review collection at scale

  1. Order delivered

    Customer receives their protein bars, shakes, or supplements.

  2. Review request email

    Automated email sent after delivery with a direct link to the review form.

  3. Reminder email

    Follow-up sent if the customer hasn't responded.

  4. Incentive reward

    Loyalty points or discount applied when the review is submitted.

With thousands of orders flowing through the store, automation is the only way to keep reviews coming in across the full catalog. No one on the team touches the process.

Reviews from every channel, in one place

Google, Facebook, and on-site reviews together

Protein Pick and Mix connects their Google My Business page (4.8 stars, 47 reviews) and Facebook page (4.7 stars, 42 ratings, 13,781 likes) directly to WiserReview. Reviews from Google and Facebook display alongside on-site product reviews, so shoppers see all the social proof in one place without visiting separate platforms.

Google reviews, Facebook reviews, and on-site product reviews all managed from a single WiserReview dashboard.

Results

Where Protein Pick and Mix is today

  • Automated review collection running across 7,000+ products
  • Google My Business reviews (4.8 stars) pulled into WiserReview
  • Facebook page reviews (4.7 stars, 13,781 likes) connected and displayed
  • 35K Instagram followers backing a brand trusted by supplement shoppers
  • Incentive-driven feedback loop with loyalty points and discounts
  • Follow-up reminders keeping response rates consistent across every SKU
Ant Rodgers
“We have over 7,000 products across hundreds of brands. Chasing reviews manually for that many SKUs was never going to work. WiserReview handles the whole thing. Requests, reminders, incentives, all running on their own.”
Ant Rodgers · Founder, Protein Pick and Mix

More stores like this

All case studies →

FAQ

About this case study

Protein Pick and Mix runs on a headless ecommerce setup with a custom frontend, based in Kent, England.

Large catalog on a headless store?

Install WiserReview, import your existing reviews during onboarding, and put verified feedback on every product page.

7-day free trial · from $6.75 a month, billed yearly